Peanut Butter Reserve Cookie™

THIS ITEM IS CUSTOM CURATED AT THE TIME OF ORDER AND REQUIRES A MINIMUM 72 HOUR NOTICE BEFORE PICKUP/DELIVERY

Brown Butter • Honey Peanut Butter • Your Choice of Signature Preserve

A timeless favorite, elevated to gourmet perfection. Our Peanut Butter Reserve Cookie™ reimagines the beloved peanut butter and jelly sandwich with luxurious ingredients, handcrafted preserves, and the signature flavor layering that defines Coastal Cottage Gourmet.

This oversized 4-inch cookie begins with rich European browned butter and Peter Pan® Honey Roasted Peanut Butter, creating a soft, bakery-style cookie with deep caramel notes, roasted peanut flavor, and an irresistibly tender center. Each cookie is delicately infused and finished with Peanut Butter Bourbon, adding smooth notes of roasted peanuts, vanilla, caramel, and oak that beautifully complement the richness of the cookie without overwhelming it.

Hidden inside is your choice of one of our handcrafted signature preserves, transforming a childhood classic into an unforgettable gourmet dessert. Every preserve is made in small batches using premium fruit and carefully selected spirits, creating a perfectly balanced burst of flavor in every bite.

While every combination is exceptional, we highly recommend our Blueberry Bourbon Preserve. The sweet blueberries, subtle honey, and smooth bourbon create an extraordinary pairing with the honey peanut butter cookie, offering a sophisticated take on the classic PB&J that has quickly become one of our customer favorites.

Choose Your Signature Filling

Customize your cookie with one of our handcrafted preserves:

🫐 Blueberry Bourbon Preserve (Our Signature Recommendation)
Sweet blueberries layered with premium bourbon and a touch of honey for an unforgettable gourmet pairing.

🍒 Black Cherry Bourbon Preserve
Rich black cherries with warm spices and bourbon create a bold, luxurious filling.

🍓 Strawberry Margarita Preserve
Bright strawberries infused with premium tequila, cognac, and orange liqueur for a vibrant citrus finish.

❤️ Cognac & Raspberry Chipotle Preserve
Ripe raspberries layered with Courvoisier Cognac and a gentle hint of smoky chipotle for a sophisticated sweet-heat experience.

Signature Flavor Notes

• European browned butter cookie

• Peter Pan® Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

• Infused and finished with Peanut Butter Bourbon

• Filled with your choice of handcrafted signature preserve

• Soft bakery-style texture with a molten fruit center

• Handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients

• Signature Coastal Cottage Gourmet flavor layering

Perfect Pairings

Enjoy alongside:

• Freshly brewed coffee

• Espresso or cappuccino

• Cold milk

• Vanilla bean ice cream

• Peanut butter bourbon served neat or over ice

• Fresh berries

• Roasted honey-glazed peanuts

Coastal Cottage Gourmet™ — The Art of Flavor. Savor It.